While, to this day, there is no official consensus about the origin of Whoopie Pies, wherever they came from, they are a delicious treat northeasterners have enjoyed for nearly 100 years! If you’ve never had the pleasure of eating a whoopie pie, you may not know that they are made of two soft pieces of cake with a sandwich of delicious cream in the middle. The traditional Whoopie Pie is made with chocolate cake and a marshmallow filling, but at Sweet Lucille’s we’ve added a variety of new and unique flavors.
Below are some of the flavor selections we usually have on hand at Sweet Lucille’s but if you are dreaming of a flavor combination you don’t see, please contact us for a custom order ($3.00, 1/2 dozen $16, $30 per dozen).
- Classic Chocolate Whoopie Pie: Chocolate cake shells and a fluffy marshmallow filling
- Chocolate Chip Whoopie Pie: Vanilla cake with chocolate chips and a marshmallow filling
- Fluffernutter Whoopie Pie: Vanilla cake with classic peanut buttercream with fluff filling
- Red Velvet Whoopie Pie: Red velvet cake with cream cheese filling
- Half and Half Whoopie Pie: One vanilla shell and one chocolate shell with a marshmallow filling
- Root Beer Float Whoopie Pie: Vanilla cake and a root beer filling
- S’mores Whoopie Pie (Amanda’s favorite): Graham Cracker cake with chocolate ganache filling and marshmallow filling.
- Coconut Almond Whoopie Pie: Classic Chocolate shell with a coconut cream filling rolled in sliced almonds
- Salted Caramel Whoopie Pie: Salty Carmel cake with a Caramel Swiss Buttercream
- Guiltless Chocolate Whoopie Pie: Gluten-Free Chocolate pie with Vegan Vanilla butter cream filling
- Guiltless Vanilla Whoopie Pie: Gluten-Free Vanilla pie with Vegan Chocolate butter cream filling
If you’re ready to place an order for some delicious Whoopie Pies, please place an order here, or contact Sweet Lucille’s at 919-617-6555 or amandab@sweetlucillesbakery.com. You’re sure to love this Northeastern treat!
*Please note that we are not a nut free or gluten free facility; our kitchen processes many items with nuts and flour. We mark those items that are made without nuts or flour “w/o nuts” or “GF”. This means that no flour or no nuts were included in their making. If you have questions please feel free to contact us via email or directly.